In September 2025, Ofsted are planning to introduce a new report card system for schools, providing a more detailed and transparent assessment of school performance. This shift could offer an important opportunity for primary school headteachers to refine their self-evaluation processes, helping them better understand their strengths and areas for improvement. In this blog, we will explore how primary schools can use the new Ofsted report card to strengthen their self-reflection practices and support ongoing school improvement.
What is the New Ofsted Report Card?
The new proposed Ofsted report card will replace the current inspection framework, offering a more detailed breakdown of how primary schools perform in key areas. Instead of a single overall grade, the report card will assess schools across several key domains, such as:
• Teaching and Curriculum
• Leadership and management
• Opportunities for pupils to thrive and school values
• Academic progress and attainment
• Inclusivity and community involvement
This detailed feedback could provide primary school headteachers with a clearer understanding of how their school is performing across a range of areas, offering valuable insights into what is working well and where further improvements may be needed.
How Primary Schools Can Use the Report Card for Self-Evaluation
Self-evaluation is a key part of a primary school’s improvement process, helping headteachers and staff reflect on their performance, identify strengths, and address areas for development. The new
Ofsted report card offers a useful tool for supporting self-evaluation in the following ways:
1. Clearer Insights Into Specific Areas of Performance
The new report card will break down school performance into specific categories, such as the quality of teaching, curriculum, and student wellbeing. This detailed feedback allows headteachers to more easily pinpoint areas where their school is excelling and where further attention may be needed.
Actionable Step: Use the detailed feedback in each category to validate your current self-assessment. For example, if your school receives positive feedback on curriculum design but needs to improve on pupil engagement, you can adjust your self-evaluation to reflect this and set appropriate goals for improvement.
2. Identifying Key Areas for Improvement
The breakdown of the report card will allow headteachers to identify specific areas that need attention. For example, if leadership or student wellbeing is highlighted as an area of concern, schools can use this information to create targeted improvement plans.
Actionable Step: Compare the feedback in the report card with your school’s existing priorities. If the report card identifies a need to improve pupil wellbeing, for instance, this can become a key focus of your improvement plan. Set clear, actionable steps to address the identified areas.
3.Tracking Progress Over Time
The report card will allow schools to track how they are improving over time by offering a clear snapshot of performance at the time of inspection. Headteachers can use this baseline to assess how their school is progressing year on year and whether their improvement efforts are having the desired impact.
Actionable Step: Regularly track progress against the areas highlighted in the report card. For example, if one of your goals is to improve pupil progress in reading, track this over time and use the report card as a checkpoint to assess whether improvements are being made.
4. Adopting a Holistic View of School Performance
The new report card will assess a wide range of factors beyond just academic outcomes, including pupil wellbeing and community involvement. For primary schools, this holistic view is especially important, as it allows headteachers to reflect on the broader impact of their school, including how well they support students’ emotional and social development.
Actionable Step: Incorporate feedback from the report card about wellbeing, inclusivity, and community engagement into your self-evaluation process. Ensure that your improvement plans address these areas in addition to academic performance, reflecting the full spectrum of your school’s impact.
5. Supporting Evidence-Based Reflection
The report card will provide evidence-based feedback, combining quantitative data (e.g., pupil progress and attainment) with qualitative insights (e.g., leadership and management). Headteachers can use this data to strengthen their self-evaluation, ensuring that it is grounded in objective information rather than subjective impressions.
Actionable Step: Use the data in the report card, such as progress scores and pupil feedback, to support your reflections and identify areas for growth. For example, if your school’s pupil progress scores in mathematics are lower than expected, this should be reflected in your self-evaluation and become a focus for targeted improvement.
6. Encouraging Collaboration Among Staff
The detailed feedback in the report card will help foster more collaborative self-evaluation practices. By sharing the insights from the report card with staff, headteachers can create a more inclusive process, engaging teachers, governors, and other stakeholders in discussions about school performance and improvement.
Actionable Step: Share the feedback from the report card with your senior leadership team, staff, and governors. Use this as a basis for collaborative discussions about areas for improvement, involving all stakeholders in shaping the school’s improvement plan.
Preparing for the New Report Card
To make the most of the new report card, primary school headteachers should start preparing in advance. Here are a few steps schools can take to get ready:
• Review Current Self-Evaluation Processes: Consider how your existing self-evaluation practices align with the areas that will be assessed in the new report card. Make sure that your internal processes cover all of the areas that will be included in the report card, such as pupil wellbeing, inclusivity, and curriculum quality.
• Involve Staff in the Self-Evaluation Process: Engage your teaching staff in discussions about the areas the report card will assess. This can help create a shared understanding of what to focus on and build a collaborative approach to self-evaluation.
• Set Improvement Goals Aligned with the Report Card: Based on the feedback from the report card, set specific, measurable improvement goals for your school. For example, if your school’s report card highlights areas for improvement in leadership, make this a key focus of your school’s development plan.
Conclusion
The new Ofsted report card, set to launch in September 2025, offers primary school headteachers an opportunity to strengthen their school’s self-evaluation practices. By providing more detailed and specific feedback across key areas, it allows schools to identify strengths, pinpoint areas for improvement, and track progress over time. For primary schools, the report card provides a more comprehensive view of performance that reflects both academic outcomes and wider factors such as pupil wellbeing and community engagement.
By using the new report card as a tool for reflection, planning, and improvement, primary school headteachers can ensure that their self-evaluation is evidence-based and focused on continuous school improvement. Proper preparation and engagement with staff and governors will help ensure that schools can make the most of this new system when it is introduced in 2025.
Continue the Conversation
View our eBook to help you Create your own Report Card
View our full range of resources to help with Self-Evaluation
View our full range of resources to help prepare for an Ofsted Inspection
You can find us on X (Twitter) @focuseducation1 or contact us